“ It shows a bit of promise, since some of the dialogue is okay here, but, overall, this is a talky, indie bore.
“ Josh Hamilton and Olivia d'Abo's mid-day drunk scene is very enjoyable as well.
“ Jane is pretty much the ideal realization of all the odd, quirky, lovely, bizarre, pretentious, disaffected, writers I had crushes on in university and even before and after that time, and the few I was fortunate enough to date.
“These people are a little too aimless to be completely compelling.
“ As in his later films, Baumbach seems to take pity on pretentious and tremendously insecure characters while simultaneously taking delight in exposing their weaknesses to the world.
“It's funny and unpredictable, like when one unlikely romance works out while another perfect romance falls apart.
“ However, this movie hardly does that feeling justice because the characters are so unbelievably thick, annoying, uninspired, pretentious, and un- relatable.
“ Because they are pretentious posers unwilling to put forth the dedication necessary to become masters of any craft, much like the director at the time when he made this.
“ The characters are very boring and intellectual, or at least they think they are, intellectual that is.
“" The guys amuse themselves on dreary afternoons: they ask each other if they beat off; they do each others' girlfriends; they crowd around the beer bottles and cigarettes to play trivia games ("Name all 7 Jason Voorhees movies").
“ It is the only scene in the film that makes it a challenge to stay awake.
“ In general, an enjoyable film for anyone, I think.
“ For an "indy" film it is good, but every scene is too long.
“ He was also everywhere, even in some particularly banal films (Killing Zoe, anyone?
“ Talk-heavy indie is fresh and witty but boring .
“ Skippy's girlfriend Miami is still a student so he stays, Otis is scared of moving to Milwaukee, Grover's girlfriend went to Prague, thus dumping him and backing out of their plans to live in Brooklyn together, etc. It's a very indie take on a coming of age story.
“ I couldn't relate to any of them, found them all so incredibly irksome and pretentious, and there was absolutely no point to any of their narratives.
“ Forget Dazed and Confused or American Graffiti (both of which I like), this one is more intelligent, more engaging and really interesting.
“ Noah Baumbach has predicated a film, not so much on realistic conversation being that characters can often expunge a paragraph worth of ideas and ramblings without even breaking a sweat or stammering over their words, but on humorous and eminently quotable film that releases the confusing and often unorthodox mind of a young adult.
“ The guys Max and Otis are probably the most engaging out of the group of characters.
“ Pretentious, uninteresting .
“ It shows that the future can be funny or not funny, boring or stimulating, etc. In all, it tells us that life will go on no matter what we do, and that we have to make the right decisions at the right time or else we won't get what we want.
“ Did I mention there's no plot?
“ He wrote and directed it at age 25, which is a real accomplishment because the film's very compelling.
“ A waste of time for anyone who values their time and brainspace .
“ Effortlessly breathtaking.
“ Where as the two parents on the edge of divorce in the latter film are writers, in Kicking and Screaming, the two young people in the outs of their love are aspiring writers and the main's parents are going through divorce.
“"Kicking and Screaming" is an experiment, an artsy film that some will love just for being artsy and others will find boring for being exactly that way.
“ Cliché and Trite .
“It is so cliché and slow moving that it is unbearable to watch.
“ You'll like a lot of what you hear and you'll be bored by a lot of it.
“ He may be too smart to make a coherent and entertaining story about human interaction and psychology.
“ While the plot revolves around the romance between Grover and Jane, the most enjoyable and funny moments come from scenes where the housemates are just hanging out together, expounding on their somewhat pitiful lives.