“ Seaton also wrote the screenplay, basing it on an Alexander Klein book, and he must be given credit for fashioning a thoroughly believable and suspenseful story.
“ The scene where the character of Hans Holtz (young Nazi boy who wants to turn Erickson in to the authorities) is truly riveting.
“COMMENT: A well-produced and reasonably exciting spy thriller, which could have been even more forcefully dramatic given sharper playing - especially by the male lead - and more stylish direction.
“ The story is thus a true story, and that may explain the film's deeply compelling qualities.
“ The film runs for 2 hours and 20 minutes and is gripping for the entire time.
“ Suspenseful ending as well.
“George Seaton has made an entertaining movie,which does not forget to ask questions and to moot responsibility.
“ I first saw "The Conterfeit Traitor" when I was a teenager, and I remember how much I enjoyed it then.
“ A truly absorbing tale, one that can be enjoyed more than once.
“ I was ready to dismiss my liking the film as a folly of my youth because it seemed to be slow and overacted.
“ He then played his trump card, showing him his newly-signed Gestapo papers, which bore the name of Heinrich Himmler .
“Stunning location photography in and around Copenhagen is a plus factor, as is the rousing score by Alfred Newman.
“ The film really began to move when William Holden's love interest was arrested by the Gestapo, and it became emotionally absorbing to its end.
“ Classic World War II spy drama well worth watching...
“ The beginning-the first third overall-is rather tedious ,with too much voice-over.
“ compelling real spy story .
“ Engrossing despite itself.
“People who like gripping stories and great acting in a WWII setting should definitely see John Frankenheimer's "The Train" with Burt Lancaster and Paul Scofield...
“ I watched it and it turned out to be grippy and suspenseful and Holden was great.
“ A pretty engrossing film based on a real character and true events.
“This is a suspense thriller full of tension , agonisingly intriguing and entertainment.
“ This excellent movie is more than just an entertaining film, it is a document and a record, and it is so well done that it does justice to the seriousness of its subject matter.
“ However the real spy story is very compelling and the movie is able to translate some of that onto the screen.
“ Its treatment of the Germans, the Allies and the love affair is surprisingly sophisticated with many shades of gray and many interesting characters and an unexpected ending to the love affair.
“ The movie is too long and could easily lose 30 minutes here and there.
“ Think of The Counterfeit Traitor as a sprawling but engrossing three-part espionage novel with a daunting number of pages to get through.
“ Although unappealingly long - 140 minutes to be precise - The Counterfeit Traitor turns out to be an absorbing, disturbing and rather exciting wartime suspense film.
“ That leaves us with the last half of the movie and one exciting moment after another.
“One of the most intriguing characters plays a small part now:a young boy,about 12,member of the Hitlerian Youth,proud of his uniform,he will make your hair stand on end.
“ Fascinating and suspenseful spy-thriller based on true events .