“ The flow of the movie is great & engaging.
“ First-half of the film is very entertaining.
“ The movie's prime flaw is the slow pace which might test the patience of a lot of young viewers.
“ Unlike Rajshree's "Hum Aapke Hai Kaun", the film is slow and the songs and music are comparatively weak.
“ Though this movie has an old fashioned narration, repetitive camera movements, and evident studio backgrounds, altogether it wonderfully delivers a triangular chemistry between three environments; the girl, the boy and the audience.
“ Beautiful (if a bit slow) movie .
“ Aloknath does cliché in a role of Girl's father, Shahid kapoor looks fat and Shahrukhed, Amrita rao is another disaster in addition to ugly looking sets, bad costumes, hackneyed storyline, monstrous stepmother, trying-hard-to-act actors, cacophonous background music, cheap soundtracks.
“ Boring .
“ Shahid and Amrita are just insipid and boring.
“ Amrita looks simply stunning and should be taken seriously as a future major star.
“ Save yourself the pain and give this pointless movie a miss
“ Barjatya has done his homework well and has depicted a very realistic story into a well-made highly entertaining movie.
“All in all, I definitely recommend this film, its romantic, looks stunning and has a dramatic climax (I won't go into details, just in case you haven't seen it.
“That factor took my notice and when the occasion came I decided to give this boring Indian saga a go, just to see what is on the cards.